FORUM FOR ANTHROPOLOGY AND CULTURE

ANTROPOLOGICHESKIJ FORUM
RUS | ENG

Antropologicheskij forum, 2021, no. 51

 

ON THE EVOLUTION OF THE NORTHWEST COAST INDIAN COMMUNITIES (А SOVIET-AMERICAN DISCUSSION AND ITS SEQUEL)

Igor V. Kuznetsov

Institute of Linguistics, Russian Academy of Sciences
1 Bolshoy Kislovsky Lane, Moscow, Russia
i.kuznetsov()iling-ran.ru

Abstract: The article is devoted to the discussion among Soviet and U.S. scholars about the social organization of the Indians of the Northwest Coast of North America. In the classic textbooks on “primitive history”, the Indians of this region—the Tlingit, Haida, Tsimshian and Kwakwaka’wakw (Kwakiutl)—are mentioned as examples of a high degree of social differentiation based on a (fishing and maritime) foraging economy and even as instances of pre-state structures. The proposed concepts were, to varying degrees, determined by external factors: personal political views, high-profile events, or government pressure. In 1897, Franz Boas recognized the potlatch ceremony—demonstrative exchanges of gifts and destructions of surplus, a practice exotic to Europeans—as an analogue of a credit operation. This interpretation, not empirically substantiated, originated from a public campaign to legalize potlatch. In the 1930s, Julia Averkieva, a Soviet intern of Boas, interpreted some fragments of her mentor’s teaching through the Marxist class theory framework, shifting the emphasis from potlatch to slavery: the Northwest Indians allegedly began the transition to slavery from a classless system in which the potlatch was an instrument for preserving property equality. Averkieva’s interpretation became canonical in the USSR, whilst also finding some reception outside the socialist camp. In the United States, relativistic cultural interpretations dominated; domestic evolutionary Marxist models were marginal and were not rooted in the Soviet tradition. However, after the collapse of the USSR, they also became part of the research mainstream, being criticized not only from the right, but also from the left—from anarchist viewpoints.

Keywords: North American Indians, potlatch, slavery, Marxism.

To cite: Kuznetsov I., ‘Ob evolyutsii indeyskikh soobshchestv Severo-Zapadnogo poberezhya (sovetsko-amerikanskaya diskussiya i ee prodolzhenie)’ [On the Evolution of the Northwest Coast Indian Communities (A Soviet-American Discussion and Its Sequel)], Antropologicheskij forum, 2021, no. 51, pp. 141–172.

doi: 10.31250/1815-8870-2021-17-51-141-172

URL: http://anthropologie.kunstkamera.ru/files/pdf/051/kuznetsov.pdf